Tucked away in the stunning Black Hills, this incredible property at 11431 Wrangler Rd, Custer, SD offers the perfect blend of space, privacy, and modern mountain living. With 40.2 acres of private land plus direct access to an additional 80 acres of National Forest Service land, this home is a dream come true for those seeking wide-open spaces and a lifestyle close to nature. Listed at $959,000, it combines luxury, comfort, and practicality in one breathtaking package.

A Spacious Home Designed for Comfort

Built in 2006, this 3,674 sq. ft. home offers three levels of well-planned living space with 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms. Every detail reflects the character of a true Black Hills retreat. The main floor boasts a soaring vaulted ceiling, a stunning stone fireplace, and three patio doors opening onto a wrap-around deck that showcases long-distance southern views.

The kitchen and dining area provide plenty of space for entertaining, while the main floor laundry and pantry add everyday convenience. Upstairs, an open loft overlooks the great room, offering the perfect flex space for an office or reading nook.

The lower level is equally impressive, with a wet bar, family room, propane fireplace, and additional bedrooms—perfect for hosting guests or creating a private retreat for family members.

Guest Cabin and Extra Amenities

Beyond the main residence, the property includes an additional 1,166 sq. ft. guest cabin with a 302 sq. ft. loft area. Whether used for extended family, weekend visitors, or as a potential rental space, the cabin offers unmatched versatility.

There’s also a 1,120 sq. ft. detached garage with three bays. Heated and equipped with a second-floor unfinished loft, it’s ideal for storage, hobbies, or converting into even more living space.

Built for Self-Sufficiency

This property isn’t just beautiful—it’s practical and self-sufficient. A 450-foot fresh water well supplies three separate cisterns, ensuring a reliable water source. A private septic system and two propane tanks support daily living, while a fenced garden area allows you to grow your own food. With horses and pets allowed, the land is well suited for hobby farming or equestrian pursuits.

Modern life isn’t left behind either. Fiber optic internet ensures high-speed connectivity, so you can work remotely while enjoying mountain seclusion.

Natural Beauty at Your Doorstep

One of the property’s most unique features is its direct access to 80 acres of National Forest Service land. From hiking and horseback riding to snowshoeing or wildlife watching, the opportunities for recreation are endless. Living here means the Black Hills aren’t just your view—they’re your backyard.

The wrap-around deck is the perfect place to take it all in, whether you’re sipping coffee in the morning sun or watching the sunset paint the horizon.

A Motivated Seller Offering Opportunity

The sellers are motivated and even offering a $15,000 repair concession for deck and railing updates, making this an ideal time to make your move. This combination of acreage, square footage, and bonus guest cabin is rarely available at this price point in the Custer area.

With 99 days on the market and plenty of interest from buyers, opportunities like this don’t last long. If you’ve been waiting for a Black Hills property that balances seclusion, luxury, and functionality—this is it.

Why Custer, South Dakota?

Custer is one of the most desirable small towns in the Black Hills. Known for Custer State Park, Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse Memorial, and countless hiking trails, the area offers a perfect mix of adventure and small-town charm. Residents enjoy a strong sense of community, excellent local amenities, and access to year-round recreation.

Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a vacation retreat, or an investment property, Custer provides both lifestyle and long-term value.